Skip to content
LumenInsight

The School Messaging Spotlighted by an Oscar-Winning Documentary – Is It Actually Work?

When her young daughter was asked to memorize a verse celebrating Russia's "glorious army" for a school function, Nina from Moscow thought it was excessive.

She has found it challenging to protect her child from a rising number of so-called "nationalistic" initiatives in the education system.

This intensification of war-focused propaganda directed toward the country's students has been powerfully depicted for a international audience in an Oscar-winning documentary.

The film, created by a ex- school events coordinator from a small town in the Ural mountains, documents how educational activities were increasingly woven into pro-government narratives after the 2022 invasion of Ukraine.

What concerns the mother deeply is that her daughter genuinely enjoys participating in the government-sponsored programme.

"She likes her teacher, she likes her classmates – she enjoys being a part of it," she says.

She worries that openly objecting to school activities could socially isolate her daughter. On one occasion, when she kept her child home to skip a patriotic event, her daughter was upset. "My concern is her to think like she doesn't belong," she adds.

The Documentary's Footage

The documentary captures how the educator was reluctantly drawn into the state propaganda apparatus.

New ceremonies and compulsory lessons were rolled out, focused on the official perspective on history and current events.

History books were rewritten to include the latest developments, termed as a "special military operation."

These diktats have continued. Just last month, the government announced plans for a official list of play materials for nurseries to foster "patriotism."

The intended messages are unambiguous: the military campaign is necessary, and loyalty requires unquestionable support. In private, however, some children encounter contrasting views.

Children's Perspectives

One young boy, a student, excitedly lists what he has learnt in his "patriotic education" lessons: subjects ranging from arts and culture to teamwork and including robots and tanks.

"We were taught this is how to prepare for war," he says.

His mother, who opposes the war, avoids openly discussing her position in front of him, concerned he might share it in public.

"A vocal anti-war position might attract unnecessary attention," she explains.

Psychological Analysis

Balancing the gap between school messages and family beliefs is difficult, according to a child psychologist.

"A child must live in the school setting – going to school, being part of the class," she says. "This doesn't mean parents should agree with the propaganda. But there is no need in taking a confrontational position in front of your child."

She suggests parents emphasize broader principles like the importance of human life and dialogue – rather than directly confronting the school narratives.

Studies indicate younger children are especially receptive to messages from authority figures. "If you tell a small child that war is necessary, they will believe it," the psychotherapist adds.

"When parents actively diverge with state messaging, parental guidance typically wins out in the long run," states a university expert in social psychology.

However, when the state controls most media and education and different viewpoints are limited, the outcome is harder to gauge. This describes the current Russian environment.

Research into 20th-century indoctrination suggest that systemic messaging can have enduring effects, particularly when supported by the broader social environment.

Varied Implementation

The enforcement of government guidelines differs significantly across schools.

Some institutions follow them zealously, while others soften or sidestep the messaging. Individual teachers may adapt, minimize, or ignore the prescribed content.

In scenes from the documentary, children are shown handed Russian flags during a gathering to watch a announcement about a state-run youth organization.

In a separate lesson, a class is warned that the "enemy" will try to influence from within their own ranks.

Student Apathy

The patriotic lessons, called "Conversations about Important Things," are often met with boredom by older students.

One teenager from St Petersburg, a student, says they are "tedious."

"Hardly anyone participates in the discussion. We just are present and pretend to listen, then leave," she describes.

"Compelling citizens to engage in rituals of patriotism is a way of demonstrating them of the state's overwhelming power," notes a professor in Russian studies. This feeling is strengthened by controlled information and orchestrated public discourse, he adds.

To further leverage this "environment," authorities made easier the process for graduates to join the military in 2023, sometimes using financial incentives as motivation.

The teenager, who holds her parents' opposing view of the war, avoids the topic at school and is unsure what her peers truly think.

"Initially I was worried that I couldn't be friends with those who backed the war," she recalls. "Now, everyone behaves so cautiously that everything seems normal."

About the author

Matthew Walker

A data scientist and business strategist with over a decade of experience in transforming raw data into actionable insights for global enterprises.

LumenInsight

Type to search articles.